A Comparative Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Artificial Intelligence Tools in Scientific Research: A Field Study of Students at the Universities of Oran 1 and Oran 2

Authors

  • Fatima Zohra Meriah Faculty of Social Sciences, Laboratory of Applications in Psychology and Education Sciences for Development in Algeria, University of Oran 2-Mohamed Ben Ahmed, Algeria

Keywords:

artificial intelligence, academic research, university students, digital research tools, perceived usefulness

Abstract

This study investigates university students’ use of artificial intelligence (AI) and related digital tools for academic research, with particular attention to preferred applications, perceived usefulness, and reported limitations. A descriptive cross-sectional survey was conducted using a four-section online questionnaire distributed through student groups at the University of Oran 1 Ahmed Ben Bella and the University of Oran 2 Mohamed Ben Ahmed, Algeria. The final sample comprised 70 students, equally distributed between the two universities, following the exclusion of 30 incomplete responses. ChatGPT was reported by 55 respondents (78.6%), followed by Google Scholar (43; 61.4%) and ResearchGate (9; 12.9%). Students also frequently reported using Microsoft PowerPoint for presentations (62; 88.6%) and Google Translate for translation (60; 85.7%). Perceptions of tool quality were generally favorable, although the source dataset contains inconsistencies in the frequencies and percentages for certain evaluative items, which require verification against the original responses. Overall, the findings describe broad adoption of complementary tools rather than a demonstrated difference in their objective performance. The study recommends targeted training in tool selection, critical evaluation of generated content, reference verification, research integrity, and protection of participant data. Its conclusions are limited by self-reporting, non-probability recruitment, the absence of direct performance measures, and the lack of documented inferential tests.

Downloads

Published

12-10-2026

Issue

Section

Articles